Critique Group Guidelines
Mission: Writers help writers by constructively analyzing current works in progress.
Objective: The groups will provide in-depth feedback on developmental structure, plot, character, voice, dialogue, themes, tone, pacing, and reader comprehension. The group will not discuss spelling and grammar; however, such helpful guidance can be provided in notes written on the manuscript.
Group composition: Groups comprise up to four people to ensure adequate time for in-depth analysis and discussion. Where possible, writers will be placed in genre-specific groups to help facilitate clarity in feedback within genre trends and expectations
Duration: Participation is part of annual membership, with each meeting occurring twice monthly. Participants will be active until the following January, when membership and participation open up for renewal.
Attendance: Minimum participation of 80% is expected. If attendance falls below this threshold, you may be asked to leave the group. If you cannot attend a meeting, you are required to notify your group leader. If you cannot submit for a session, you are still expected to critique other members’ work.
Proceedings: The mediator will begin each meeting with a reminder of appropriate feedback, time allotments, and order of presentation. Analytical notes from each critiquing member should proceed on the same body of work. Each critiquer will have five minutes to give their key-point statements, followed by five minutes for the writer to ask questions. All marked-up pages are then returned to the writer. This provides roughly 20-30 minutes per submission. The mediator will then open the floor for the next writer’s project. This procedure should repeat until all the material is discussed. After the session, the pages for the next meeting should be distributed.
Submission Guidelines:
Length: Original work less than 5,000 words.
Font Size: 12 pt.
Paragraph Spacing: 2.0
Roles:
A critique group is neither a “beat down” of the writer nor a showcase of the critiquer's skill at pointing out errors.
Critiquer: Give verbal feedback on developmental structure, plot, character, voice, dialogue, tone, themes, tone, pacing, and comprehension is acceptable. No comments regarding grammar are allowed. Leave any such notes on the material for the writer to reference on his/her/their own time.
A suggestive and agreement system will be in place concerning comments. While it would be excessive to expect a 1:1 ratio on suggestive/agree comments, it will be expected that
there should be at least one agree comment for every two suggestive comments.
For example, “(1)” The character dialogue is flat here.” (2) “Also, you have the character standing and then sitting without explanation.” (3) “But you describe the scene itself so vividly, especially..”In this example, there are two suggestive comments, (1) and (2), followed by an agree comment, (3).
Furthermore, critiques must be constructive. Telling a writer their submission is garbage or terrible has zero artistic value. Obviously, a critiquer has the right to feel that what is written is terrible. Still, their role in the group is to offer structural insight and suggest improvement opportunities. Comments should hit the key points and be frugal for the time allotment. No questions are allowed to prevent triggering a response from the writer.
Remember, analyze the work, not the writer.
Writer: Writers are not allowed to read their material. Meaning and style should be evident as it is written. The writer cannot defend their work during the critique. Instead, after all comments are received, the writer will be given time to ask clarifying questions or suggestions for improvement. These questions will be limited to what they can do differently and how they can improve the work.
Mediator: It is vital to keep the group moving forward productively. At the beginning of every session, the group should be reminded to use appropriate constructive critiques and avoid defensive explanations. If a member moves off-topic, begins to discuss grammatical errors, or takes too much of the group's time, it is necessary to redirect the group on track. The mediator’s job is to track time and call an end to the meeting. At this point, the next session's pages will be distributed for consideration. The order of writing presented should rotate from meeting to meeting, allowing for each writer the opportunity of going first every two months.
Non-discrimination Policy
Cartersville Area Writers complies with applicable federal civil rights laws and prohibits discrimination on the basis of color, national origin, age, disability, or sex. Cartersville Area Writer’s critique groups do not exclude people or treat them differently because of race, color, national origin, age, disability, or sex.
For questions or concerns please contact us at Cartersvilleareawriters@gmail.com